The intended audience for my chosen article From Spaghetti and Meatballs through Hawaiian Pizza to Sushi: The Changing Nature of Ethnicity in American Restaurants is obviously social anthropologists and others who study human behavior and culture trends in a professional situation. This is apparent by the terminology used in the article; I consider myself someone who comprehends an expanded vocabulary and this was a difficult read at times.
For example, the opening line of the article reads: “(t)his article studies American restaurant menus from the 1960s throughout the 1990s as revealing a symbolic expression of ethnicity and as an indicator of a social construct” (Gvion & Trostler, 2008, p. 950). It is not completely foreign language, but that is not conversational language. Overall, the article had a professional and technical tone that could quite easily and quickly bore the average person.
To summarize, the article discusses the influx of non-Anglo influences upon restaurant menus in America. In the 1960s, menu choices included what we now consider pretty tame and common items that have very little “ethnicity” in comparison to restaurant and menu choices now available. It was what was considered a “melting pot”, where certain ethnic dishes were served with an obvious American flavoring and interpretation along side typical American cuisine.
Throughout the 1970s, the variety of ethnic choices grew and methods of cooking were moving more to the traditional. The 1980s brought about more ethically-centered restaurants, mostly found in the ethno-centric pockets of large cities; i.e. Little Italy, Chinatown, etc. Once the 1990s rolled around, the more openness to outside cultures, traditions, and food choices became available. In fact, it became fashionable to expose your palate to exotic cuisine.
Overall, the article was very interesting once I made sense of the technical jargon used throughout. I would have liked a more casual approach and more examples that I and the common reader could relate to. I think that was the most difficult part of the article, there were paragraphs that read quite easily and just as I was getting more emotionally invested into the story it was telling, it dropped that line of thought or added in technical wording that immediately made my mind wander.
The concept was definitely interesting though, and it made me reflect a lot on my experiences at so-called ethnic restaurants. I am not a world traveler so my exposure to true authentic cuisine from outside of our country is admittedly very narrow. This article also made me think about how much of a choice I truly have in trying out new flavors in this country. I try to make an effort to visit ethnic restaurants, but I know I haven’t nearly experienced enough.
References
Gvion, L. & Trostler, N. (2008). From Spaghetti and Meatballs through Hawaiian Pizza to Sushi: The Changing Nature of Ethnicity in American Restaurants. Journal of Popular Culture, 41(6) 950-974. Retrieved July 14, 2009 from
http://0-journals.ohiolink.edu.olink...0_fsamthnoeiar
7.20.2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I liked how you critiqued the article, especially for how technical it was. You did a great job of explaining what the article was about and what it meant to you. The critique kept me interested from beginning to end
ReplyDeleteI know how you feel. So many times I think I've stumbled on something that will be a good resource, but as a start to read the article it takes me someplace I don't even understand.
ReplyDeleteIt was nice to see someone actually discuss how these articles change directions so quickly.
I liked your analysis. I actually looked at this article when choosing one for my own critique and I decided to pass because I found it quite difficult to read. I think you did a great job and I agree that we, especially in Columbus, have a very diverse selection of restaurants. Things have definitely changed in the past 30-40 years when it comes to dining.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like it would have been a very interesting artilce to read. I haven't been to a lot of different country's but I have been to a lot of different states and always enjoy eating the local diet, although sometimes it is a little scary. Don't every try poi in Hawaii. Ugh. It sounds like the author did a nice job relating the changes in food menuse to the changes in American culture, a culture which was just coming into its own as a mixture of cultures. Nice job with the summary.
ReplyDelete